Mueller’s preliminary revelations singe, not burn

**Need FOX Information Halftime Report in your inbox on daily basis? Enroll right here.**

On the roster: Mueller’s preliminary revelations singe, not burn – Kelly: ‘Let the authorized justice system work’ – Bipartisan blowback for Fb, Twitter – GOP might section in tax cuts over 5 years – Boss blanches at lavatory bobcat


Washington remains to be gnawing on Monday’s prison expenses from Particular Counsel Robert Mueller like an Eternal Gobstopper.

However in reality, there isn’t way more diet to be obtained that hasn’t already been extracted.

Two senior Trump marketing campaign officers acquired lit up for alleged shady dealings with Russia previous to their work for now-President Trump. One lower-level marketing campaign official pleaded responsible this summer season and appears to have been working for the prosecution previous to Monday’s announcement.

We now have no option to know what number of days or even weeks or months it’s going to take to place all that in perspective. It’s equally cheap to counsel that that is the fizzle of a moist wick as it’s to say that it’s the smoldering punk that will likely be utilized to a robust rocket.

We can not assist however marvel, even when questioning is fruitless. However what could also be fruitful, although, is to contemplate what success or failure would appear to be in order that we’re in a position to acknowledge it once we get there.

There’s now a second recognized occasion during which people related to the Trump marketing campaign have been desperate to obtain “dust” on Hillary Clinton from sources recognized to be related to the Kremlin.

However, to be honest, lets say virtually the identical factor concerning the Clinton marketing campaign, which financed and subcontracted a dirt-digging expedition by a agency with its personal Kremlin ties.

Group Trump might have acted in an amateurish trend, however either side have bragged about their willingness to make use of Kremlin crud to win an election. We might lament this second as People, however so be it.

There’s additionally a suggestion that the Trump marketing campaign might have had foreknowledge of the hacking of Clinton marketing campaign emails by Russian operatives. This may take us into the realm of a citizen’s responsibility to report prison misconduct. For those who knew that one in all your nation’s foes was participating in what’s tantamount to cyberwarfare, what’s your obligation to tell authorities?

However even when somebody in or across the marketing campaign knew concerning the Boris and Natasha bit, it will most likely be a matter of passing political consequence.

As we’ve got mentioned many instances earlier than, Trump’s success was predicated on the extraordinary loyalty of a comparatively small variety of supporters. It’s honest to level out that Trump’s assist was already in a trough earlier than Monday’s bombshells, however it will even be sensible to do not forget that Trump wasn’t that rather more common than he’s now on the day he received the presidency.

It’s most likely secure to say {that a} revelation like Russia tipping off marketing campaign staffers to hacked emails and even the timing of their leaks is priced in to Trump’s present ranges of assist. Offered that Trump himself was not conscious, such a revelation would doubtless be greeted with little shock, even when served with copious quantities of concern.

What could be ruinous for Trump, nonetheless, wouldn’t be the revelation that Russia had helped him, however that his marketing campaign had helped Russia. And on that rely, there was no proof of malfeasance.

What worries Republicans in Washington is the likelihood that somebody in Trump’s make use of or orbit supplied info to Russian operatives to coordinate assaults. If any American supplied polling information or strategic recommendation to assist Russia’s hack assaults on election officers or to focus on faux information dumps, it will be laborious for even probably the most cynical or craven Republicans to face by their man.

Conspiring with a hostile international energy is a really totally different factor than merely benefitting by the unhealthy actions of that energy.

However until Mueller can get there, this scandal will doubtless be a survivable one for Trump. With the assistance of the Clintons, Trump’s group has outlined down acceptable habits for opposition analysis and soiled methods. There’s most likely not sufficient spin in all of the world, although, to make regular the thought of conspiring.


“Cash is, with propriety, thought of because the very important precept of the physique politic; as that which sustains its life and movement, and allows it to carry out its most important features.” – Alexander Hamilton, Federalist No. 30


Eric Metaxas
, creator of a simply revealed biography of Martin Luther provides a Reformation Day meditation on what that Augustinian monk loosed upon the world 500 years in the past as we speak. WSJ: “He didn’t intend to be defiant or to trigger bother. And he definitely didn’t plan to shake the foundations of the church he cherished and obediently served. … The highly effective concepts Luther’s writings conveyed would in time result in just about all the pieces we now take without any consideration within the fashionable world. … Within the coming centuries, this angle would assist elevate the ideas of spiritual pluralism, tolerance, democracy and freedom. … However by humbly elevating the questions he had in 1517, after which by responding to the assaults that adopted as honestly and punctiliously as he might, Luther ended up cracking the good edifice of medieval Christendom in twain. And for good and for ailing each, out of that opening the long run itself appeared to fly.”

Flag on the play? –
E-mail us at

HALFTIMEREPORT@FOXNEWS.COM together with your ideas, feedback or questions.


Trump internet job-approval score: -20.6factors

Change from one week in the past: Unchanged

[President Trump’s rating is set by subtracting his common job disapproval score within the 5 most up-to-date, methodologically sound public polls from his common approval score, calculated in the identical trend.]


Fox Information: “In a wide-ranging interview on Fox Information’ ‘The Ingraham Angle’ Monday evening, hours after expenses have been introduced towards former Trump marketing campaign chairman Paul Manafort, White Home chief of employees John Kelly stated the administration believes the legislation ought to run its course earlier than leaping to conclusions. ‘All the actions, as I perceive it, that [Paul Manafort and his aide Rick Gates] have been indicted for have been lengthy earlier than they ever met Donald Trump, or had any affiliation with the marketing campaign,’ Kelly stated. ‘I feel the response of the administration is let the authorized justice system work — everybody’s … presumed harmless and we’ll see the place it goes.’ Requested if a particular counsel is critical concerning the latest revelations that the Clinton marketing campaign and Democratic Nationwide Committee funded analysis that led to the controversial file of allegations about President Trump’s connections to Russia, Kelly stated he believes U.S. residents have a proper to know what’s occurring behind the scenes of their authorities.”

Turley: Manafort made headlines, however Gates is the true story –
USA At this time: “It’s the Washington model of the Academy Awards. … The winners are former Trump marketing campaign chairman Paul Manafort and his former deputy Rick Gates. Manafort was no shock, however Gates’ choice within the supporting actor class was probably the most notable facet of the indictment. … Gates might effectively seal a case towards his former affiliate if he have been to go all in on the prosecution’s narrative. If he might implicate Manafort and probably others, Gates might effectively stroll with little or no jail time. This is the reason charging him with Manafort maximized the strain. For Gates, going to trial with Manafort is a chilling prospect alone. Manafort has lengthy had a controversial fame in Washington as somebody who actively cashed in with shady worldwide figures and purchasers.”

Bannon dumps on Trump’s attorneys –
Every day Beast: “Steve Bannon spoke on the telephone together with his outdated boss, Donald Trump, on Monday and provided a message: get your self some new attorneys. The previous White Home chief strategist has grown more and more involved that the president’s authorized group is falling down on the job, proving too accommodating to Particular Counsel Robert Mueller, and leaving Trump susceptible as former marketing campaign aides are handed indictments. ‘By way of Steve’s considering of how the president is dealing with this, yeah, he thinks the authorized group was not ready for what occurred as we speak—they’re not serving the president effectively,’ a supply near Bannon stated. Added one other confidant: Bannon believes Ty Cobb and John Dowd, the highest two attorneys on the president’s authorized group, ‘are asleep on the wheel.’”

GOP senators say Mueller is secure –
The Hill: “Senate Republicans, together with a few of President Trump’s sharpest GOP critics, are rebuffing Democratic calls for to go laws defending particular counsel Robert Mueller as his investigation into the 2016 election ramps up. ’I can’t think about any administration taking a transfer like that,’ Sen. Bob Corker (R-Tenn.) informed reporters Monday when requested if laws to defend Mueller from a possible firing was needed. … However Republicans argue the laws isn’t wanted, for now, as a result of they don’t consider Trump would fireplace or attempt to have the Division of Justice (DOJ) fireplace Mueller, who’s extensively revered in Washington.”

Carter Web page ‘might have’ emailed Papadopoulos about Russia – Politico: “Carter Web page, a international coverage adviser to Donald Trump’s 2016 presidential marketing campaign, stated he might need exchanged emails about Russia with a fellow adviser who pleaded responsible to mendacity to the FBI in particular counsel Robert Mueller’s investigation into the president’s marketing campaign and potential collusion with the Russian authorities. ‘It might have come up, yeah,’ Web page informed MSNBC’s Chris Hayes when requested whether or not he might have exchanged emails with George Papadopoulos and whether or not the 2 mentioned Russia.”

Prison case clouds Clovis affirmation – WaPo: “Sam Clovis was at all times a fairly suspect choose by President Trump to grow to be the chief science adviser on the Agriculture Division — principally as a result of he’s not truly a scientist. His chief qualification for the job appears to be that he was nationwide co-chairman of Trump’s 2016 marketing campaign. … And now we will add another excuse his nomination could possibly be a key battle for Democrats — and a dicey proposition for Republicans. The Washington Submit [reported] that Clovis was a type of nameless marketing campaign officers cited in former Trump aide George Papadopoulos’s plea deal. Clovis was the one named as a ‘marketing campaign supervisor,’ and he each praised Papadopoulos’s efforts to dealer a gathering with the Russians as ‘nice work’ and later urged Papadopoulos to make the journey slightly than Trump.”


WaPo: “Fb plans to inform lawmakers on Tuesday that 126 million of its customers might have seen content material produced and circulated by Russian operatives, many instances greater than the corporate had beforehand disclosed concerning the attain of the net affect marketing campaign focusing on American voters. The corporate beforehand reported that an estimated 10 million customers had seen adverts purchased by Russian-controlled accounts and pages. … Google acknowledged for the primary time Monday that it had discovered proof that Russian operatives used the corporate’s platforms to affect American voters, saying in a weblog put up that it had discovered 1,108 movies with 43 hours of content material associated to the Russian effort on YouTube. It additionally discovered $4,700 price of Russian search and show adverts. Twitter additionally plans to inform congressional investigators that it has recognized 2,752 accounts managed by Russian operatives and greater than 36,000 bots that tweeted 1.Four million instances throughout the election, in accordance with a draft of Twitter’s testimony obtained by The [Washington] Submit. The corporate beforehand reported 201 accounts linked to Russia.”

Specialists supply methods to save lots of Fb – NYT: “…the cloud over Fb extends far past Russia. Critics say the corporate’s central position in fashionable communication has undermined the information enterprise, cut up People into partisan echo chambers and ‘hijacked’ our minds with a product designed to maintain us hooked on the social community. After all, criticism of Fb and its founder, Mark Zuckerberg, is straightforward to come back by; options aren’t as clear. We requested 9 technologists, lecturers, politicians and journalists to suggest the steps they’d take to enhance Fb — as a product, an organization or each.”


Bloomberg: “Home tax writers are discussing a gradual phase-in for President Donald Trump and Republican leaders’ proposed company tax-rate lower — on a schedule that might put the speed at 20 % in 2022, in accordance with a member of the chamber’s tax-writing committee and an individual aware of the discussions. The phase-in plan is beneath dialogue, however isn’t but remaining, stated a member of the Home Methods and Means Committee, who requested to not be named as a result of the discussions are non-public. Different members stated they deliberate to debate the proposal throughout a personal assembly Monday afternoon. Home Methods and Means Chairman Kevin Brady informed reporters Monday that there hasn’t been a choice but. … The phase-in proposal would scale back the speed from its present 35 % charge by three proportion factors a yr beginning in 2018. If adopted, it will delay among the financial results Trump and his advisers have sought to emphasise from their tax cuts.”

Collins lists her calls for on tax plan –
Bloomberg: “Republican Senator Susan Collins of Maine stated Monday she’s opposed to 2 tax breaks for the rich that her social gathering leaders are pushing for, indicating that her vote received’t be simple to win on President Donald Trump’s high legislative precedence. … Collins, a average Republican who performed a decisive position in thwarting a number of iterations of Obamacare substitute laws, provided her most pointed feedback on her priorities for a tax invoice up to now. She added that the construction of the property tax — a 40 % levy utilized to estates price greater than $5.49 million for people or $10.98 million for {couples} — means it avoids hitting ‘the overwhelming majority of family-owned companies and farms and ranches.’ She stated she’s open to adjusting the cutoff stage barely upward.”


Fortune: “California billionaire and political activist Tom Steyer has put some severe cash behind impeaching Trump – and it appears to be like like his efforts is likely to be paying off, at the least by way of signatures. On October 20, Steyer launched a marketing campaign to question Trump, with an advert that rapidly went viral and a petition to get others to hitch his effort. In line with sources, Steyer spent ‘effectively over’ ten million {dollars} to air the advert in all 50 states. The efforts rapidly triggered the wrath of Trump, who tweeted on Friday that “Wacky & completely unhinged Tom Steyer, who has been combating me and my Make America Nice Once more agenda from starting, by no means wins elections!” However in accordance with figures acquired by Axios, Steyer’s petition has already collected multiple million signatures up to now—1,119,720, to be precise.”

Pelosi endorses Feinstein for re-election to Senate –Fox Information: “Home Minority Chief Nancy Pelosi backed fellow Californian Sen. Dianne Feinstein’s re-election bid on Monday. ‘Dianne Feinstein is uniquely positioned to defend California towards Donald Trump’s fixed assaults on well being care, immigration, and voting rights,’ Pelosi stated in an announcement. ‘Senator Feinstein’s standing within the Senate is a supply of energy to California and is particularly wanted right now. I proudly assist her re-election.’ Feinstein hailed Pelosi as a ‘good friend’ in an announcement welcoming her endorsement. ‘I sit up for persevering with to work together with her for California and towards Donald Trump’s assaults on our state and our residents,’ Feinstein stated.”

Q Ballot: Northam maintains broad lead in Virginia –
Quinnipiac College: “With overwhelming assist from non-white voters and double-digit leads amongst each women and men, Democratic Lt. Gov. Ralph Northam holds a 53 – 36 % doubtless voter lead over Republican Ed Gillespie within the Virginia governor’s race, in accordance with a Quinnipiac College ballot launched as we speak. Libertarian Celebration candidate Cliff Hyra has three %. At this time’s outcome compares to a 53 – 39 % doubtless voter lead for Northam in an October 18 survey by the unbiased Quinnipiac College. Non-white doubtless voters again the Democrat 72 – 15 %, with 2 % for Hyra. White voters are divided 46 – 46 %, with Four % for Hyra. Girls again Northam 56 – 36 %, with 1 % for Hyra. Males go Democratic 51 – 37 %, with 5 % for Hyra.”


Rep. Jeb Hensarling, R-Texas, received’t search re-electionDallas Morning Information

Mattis, Tillerson inform Congress there’s no must replace 15-year-old struggle authorizationNYT

FBI is investigating Puerto Rico’s determination to provide $300 million contract to a Montana power agencyWashEx

Noemie Emery: Trump’s critics perceive all the pieces however crucial factor –WashEx


“I feel they’re attending to the underside of a few of these info. I don’t assume all of those info are main the place the Democrats wished. However that’s a part of the rationale why we’ve got investigations and that’s why we comply with the info.” – Sen. Mike Lee, on “Fox Information @ Night time,” discussing the tempo of the varied congressional investigations on alleged Russian interference within the 2016 presidential election.


“Re your assertion that ‘the constituency for extra beneficiant advantages is simply as potent, if no more so, than the one for decrease taxes,’ I need to level out the realm that I feel begs for reform: using IRS and tax legislation to offer ‘the brand new welfare.’ I feel if individuals realized how a lot cash goes out in ‘refundable tax credit,’ – i.e. cash paid by ‘refunds’ to individuals who haven’t paid any taxes within the first place, they’d be appalled. This can be a becoming place for decreasing authorities giveaways whereas tightening up the deficit issues within the tax reform course of. And the argument that this ‘raises taxes on the center class’ needs to be simple to counter: If an individual finally ends up with a zero tax legal responsibility, that particular person can’t argue that his taxes have been raised!” – Anna Marie Davis, Douglasville, Ga.

[Ed. observe: An excellent level, Ms. Davis! To be able to acquire stimulative tax cuts, Republicans have for years traded Democrats for what are primarily welfare funds administered by the IRS. It insulates the GOP from claims that they’re handmaidens to the rich and since neither social gathering cares notably about deficit spending today it’s a straightforward concession to make. One of many chief issues in Washington as we speak is that we use the fallacious implements for the fallacious jobs. The Federal Reserve is meant to maintain our financial provide, however then is known as to behave as an employment company. The Division of Protection is meant to guard us from our enemies, however we use it as all the pieces from a laboratory for social experiments to a world aid company. However it’s the IRS that’s most likely probably the most egregiously misused. A sub-department of the Treasury charged with amassing taxes is used to manage political speech, encourage virtuous habits, encourage investments thought fascinating and, sure, present welfare funds. All of these issues might or might not be good goals for the federal government, however it is rather troublesome to have a worthwhile dialog about these matters when they’re being appended to the duties of unrelated companies.]

“What then are we to make of an appointed authorities official who so blatantly makes use of blackmail for what seem like political objective: ‘We’re after energy and we imply it….There’s no option to rule harmless males. The one energy any authorities has is to crack down on criminals. Effectively, when there aren’t sufficient criminals, one makes them. One declares so many issues to be a criminal offense that it turns into unattainable for males to stay with out breaking legal guidelines. Who needs a nation of law-abiding residents? What’s there in that for anybody? However simply go the type of legal guidelines that may neither be noticed nor enforced nor objectively interpreted – and also you create a nation of law-breakers – and you then money in on the guilt. Now that’s the system…’ (Dr. Ferris to Hank Rearden – Atlas Shrugged)” – Patsy Fields, Aliso Viejo, Calif.

[Ed. observe: I might counsel, Ms. Fields, that “political objective” and “blackmail” are each within the eyes of the beholders. Political prosecutions are baneful issues to republics. The criminalization of politics is a trademark of totalitarian states and banana republics. That’s why when some radical Democrats demanded prosecutions of Bush administration officers for his or her alleged misdeeds, together with the previous president himself, cheap individuals in each events stated no. We discuss so much concerning the presumption of goodwill in political opponents, even when there’s proof on the contrary. That’s notably true on this case. Siccing prosecutors in your political opponents is nearly at all times a nasty thought. You might have concluded that Robert Mueller’s investigation falls into that class, and since you maintain that perception, you see what would in any other case be regular prosecutorial conduct as blackmail. I’ve not seen any convincing proof but that Mueller is a partisan or that his inquest is motivated for political benefit. However, we must always at all times be paying shut consideration on that rely, lest we fall right into a entice that has hobbled many countries.]

Share your coloration commentary: E-mail us at

HALFTIMEREPORT@FOXNEWS.COM and please ensure to incorporate your identify and hometown.


AP: “A small-town Oklahoma newspaper writer discovered a startling front-page story virtually in his newsroom: There was a hissing bobcat within the lavatory. Sapulpa Herald writer Darren Sumner says the wild animal jumped at him one latest morning as he was heading into the restroom at his workplace in Sapulpa, a Tulsa suburb. Sumner shut the door and trapped the grownup male cat inside till police and a recreation warden arrived. Wildlife management staff captured the bobcat in a cage and launched it in close by Pawnee County. Neither Sumner nor the wild cat was injured within the confrontation. Sumner stated the animal doubtless acquired into his constructing by an open door.”

Chris Stirewalt is the politics editor for Fox Information. Brianna McClelland contributed to this report. Need FOX Information Halftime Report in your inbox on daily basis? Enroll right here.

Chris Stirewalt joined Fox Information Channel (FNC) in July of 2010 and serves as politics editor primarily based in Washington, D.C.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

    is typing...

    Fill in the form below to send us a message.

    Send Message Cancel